It was Nigel Shepherd, writer, photographer, BMG mountain guide, who when an instructor at Plas-y-Brenin, North Wales wrote: 'Does British climbing really need an organisation such as the BMC (British Mountaineering Council)?' Especially as the organisation is adept at wasting taxpayers and members money:
The much acclaimed Festival of Climbing arranged by the BMC in December, 2001, lost £54,000. A guide-book stock write-off, spread over two years, cost £108,000. The trumpeted National Mountaineering Exhibition at Rheged (it failed), Cumbria, cost the BMC £40,000. Postage alone of Summit magazine, published by Greenshires the owners of the then, High Mountain Sport and On the Edge, cost £40,000 and the Mountain Services, a new commercial wing of the BMC,originally set-up to make money, cost £51,000.
In 2001 ironically, Donald Trelford investagive journalist wrote: 'The BMC is at the top of its profession.'?? Contradicting his earlier newspaper article regarding the lack of safety in climbing / mountaineering. But then he was invited to visit PyB where: something happened. If the BMC were a trading company, it would be bankrupt as its current assets are £22,000 in the red. Government and members, give the BMC in exess of £1,000,000 per annum to waste on too many staff, too many 'officers' and flawed business practice's. Twenty years on from the original observation by Mr Shepherd, and the same question can still be asked. Does British climbing really need an organisation such as the BMC?
In 2007, 10,000 expansion bolts were purchaced by the BMC and flooded UK climbing.